| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Tampa | Jimi Kiner | 473 | Drury | 409 | Geneva, Ohio |
| 2023 | UIndy | Brent Noble | 527 | Drury | 450.5 | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| 2022 | Queens (N.C.) | Jeff Dugdale | 607.5 | Drury | 522 | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2021 | Queens (N.C.) | Jeff Dugdale | 561 | UIndy | 369 | Birmingham, Ala. |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | Queens (N.C.) | Jeff Dugdale | 606 | Delta State | 364.5 | Indianapolis |
| 2018 | Queens (N.C.) | Jeff Dugdale | 558 | California Baptist | 307 | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2017 | Queens (N.C.) | Jeff Dugdale | 563.5 | Drury | 350 | Birmingham, Ala. |
| 2016 | Queens (N.C.) | Jeff Dugdale | 449 | Lindenwood | 299.5 | Indianapolis |
| 2015 | Queens (N.C.) | Jeff Dugdale | 433.5 | Drury | 417.5 | Indianapolis |
| 2014 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 569.5 | Wayne State (Mich.) | 358.5 | Geneva, Ohio |
| 2013 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 546 | Florida Southern | 397 | Birmingham, Ala. |
| 2012 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 473 | UC San Diego | 400 | Mansfield, Texas |
| 2011 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 600.5 | UC San Diego | 345 | San Antonio |
| 2010 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 538 | Incarnate Word | 403 | Canton, Ohio |
| 2009 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 543 | Wayne State (Mich.) | 504.5 | Houston |
| 2008 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 523.5 | Missouri S&T | 336 | Missouri S&T |
| 2007 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 665.5 | North Dakota | 485 | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 2006 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 649 | Cal State Bakersfield | 543.5 | Indianapolis |
| 2005 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 726 | Cal State Bakersfield | 480 | Orlando, Fla. |
| 2004 | Cal State Bakersfield | Bob Steele | 718.5 | Drury | 586 | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 2003 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 612 | Cal State Bakersfield | 535 | North Dakota |
| 2002 | Cal State Bakersfield | Bob Steele | 529 | North Dakota | 507 | Orlando, Fla. |
| 2001 | Cal State Bakersfield | Bob Steele | 621 | Drury | 562.5 | Canton, Ohio |
| 2000 | Cal State Bakersfield | Bob Steele | 687 | Drury | 630 | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 1999 | Drury | Brian Reynolds | 829 | Cal State Bakersfield | 557 | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 1998 | Cal State Bakersfield | Bob Steele | 730 | Drury | 637 | Ashland |
| 1997 | Oakland | Peter Hovland | 767 | Drury | 623 | San Antonio |
| 1996 | Oakland | Peter Hovland | 869.5 | Cal State Bakersfield | 640 | North Dakota |
| 1995 | Oakland | Peter Hovland | 890 | Cal State Bakersfield | 573 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1994 | Oakland | Peter Hovland | 791 | Cal State Bakersfield | 718.5 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1993 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 951 | Oakland | 549.5 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1992 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 910 | Clarion | 481 | North Dakota |
| 1991 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 853 | Oakland | 652 | Milwaukee |
| 1990 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 830 | Oakland | 686 | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 1989 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 571 | Oakland | 406 | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 1988 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 397 | Oakland | 344.5 | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 1987 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 479.5 | Oakland | 246 | Long Beach, Calif. |
| 1986 | Cal State Bakersfield | Ernie Maglischo | 549 | Cal State Northridge | 438 | Orlando, Fla. |
| 1985 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 488 | Cal State Bakersfield | 417.5 | Orlando, Fla. |
| 1984 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 319.5 | Oakland | 226 | Hofstra |
| 1983 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 352.5 | Oakland | 347.5 | Long Beach, Calif. |
| 1982 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 444 | Puget Sound | 244.5 | Clarion |
| 1981 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 349 | Oakland | 338 | Youngstown State |
| 1980 | Oakland | Ernie Maglischo | 312 | Cal State Northridge | 263 | Youngstown State |
| 1979 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 384 | Oakland | 170 | Northern Michigan |
| 1978 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 304 | Chico State | 282 | Springfield |
| 1977 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 326 | UC Irvine | 305 | Youngstown State |
| 1976 | Chico State | Ernie Maglischo | 428 | Cal State Northridge | 283 | Springfield |
| 1975 | Cal State Northridge | Pete Accardy | 277 | UC Irvine | 210 | Cleveland State |
| 1974 | Chico State | Ernie Maglischo | 285 | UC Davis | 227 | Long Beach State |
| 1973 | Chico State | Ernie Maglischo | 262 | UC Irvine | 212 | Wayne State (Mich.) |
| 1972 | Eastern Michigan | Mike Jones | 222 | UC Irvine/Cal State Northridge | 164 | Washington & Lee |
| 1971 | UC Irvine | Ed Newland | 242 | South Florida | 176 | Springfield |
| 1970 | UC Irvine | Ed Newland | 230 | Springfield | 166 | Oakland |
| 1969 | UC Irvine | Albert Irwin | 248 | Kenyon | 190 | Springfield |
| 1968 | Long Beach State | Don Gambril | 349 | Texas-Arlington | 216 | Emory |
| 1967 | UC Santa Barbara | Rock Rowland | 255.5 | UC Irvine | 246 | Commerce, Calif. |
| 1966 | San Diego State | Bill Burgess | 243.5 | San Jose State | 213 | Illinois State |
| 1965 | San Diego State | Bill Burgess | 168.5 | Long Beach State | 147 | Illinois State |
| 1964 | Bucknell | Robert Latour | 83 | East Carolina | 50 | Grove City |